Static-Line Value and Clash

Your task is to compare the received value and clash markers for a selected static line while keeping the result conditional. The line must already be selected or explicitly related, must be static, and must carry its earlier calendar assessment as a separate field. Strength is not an extra gate supplied by the cited timing statement.

Received statement and course derivation

Marker in the received text	Symbolic branch operation	UAYA record
Value	use the selected line’s own branch	list matching dates only inside the declared horizon
Clash	use the selected line’s fixed clash partner	list matching dates only inside the declared horizon

The source statement does not supply a universal day-versus-month ranking. Preserve alternatives and the question’s declared horizon.

Invented calculation: static Shen

Invented illustration; no outcome. Suppose a selected Shen line is nonmoving and has no unresolved void, bound, frame, transformation, clash, or Dark Moving condition.

subject: selected static Shen line
value branch: Shen
fixed clash partner: Yin
candidate comparison: first matching Shen and Yin dates inside the declared horizon
ranking: not supplied by the source

The calendar search turns the Yin branch event into a date. The branch relation by itself does not establish an exact Gregorian day.

Counterexample: incomplete calendar

subject: selected static Shen line
question date or day-pillar anchor: missing
output: symbolic Shen/Yin comparison only; exact dating stopped

Do not invent a Gregorian date when the calendar anchor is missing. A weak line is not an outcome forecast either; preserve its assessment and avoid strengthening the timing claim merely to keep the sequence moving.

Keep the source scope visible

The checked timing chapter in Zengshan Buyi lists value and clash for a static main line (静而逢值、逢冲). It does not present either marker as proof of a real-world event.

Record the layers accurately:

• received statement: value or clash;
• UAYA worksheet: derive both symbolic branches, then list only dates supported by the declared horizon and complete calendar record;
• scope boundary: no certain event and no invented ranking.

Trap: strength is not event direction

The strength assessment describes the line’s input condition. A value or clash candidate describes a symbolic calendar comparison. Neither says that the external matter is favorable or certain.

Source note

The received comparison appears in Zengshan Buyi, vol. 1, “General Notes on Response Times for the Various Categories” (各门类应期总注章), checked composite printed p. 48 / PDF physical p. 49, beginning 静而逢值、逢冲. The horizon and record controls are UAYA teaching conventions.

Next step

Contrast static timing with lines already marked active: handle moving and Dark Moving candidates.